Sep 29, 2024: The case against restarting Three Mile Island’s Unit-1


Radioactive: The Women of Three Mile Island

Did you catch "The Meltdown: Three Mile Island" on Netflix?
TMI remains a danger and TMIA is working hard to ensure the safety of our communities and the surrounding areas.
Learn more on this site and support our efforts. Join TMIA. To contact the TMIA office, call 717-233-7897.

    

image.png
 December 23, 2024

California state body approves rate increase for Diablo Canyon life extension

By ExchangeMonitor
The California Public Utilities Commission last week approved $723 million in rate increases to let Pacific Gas & Electric Co. keep the state’s last nuclear power plant open through 2025, media reported.
 
The increases would cover operations of the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant from Sept. 1, 2023 through Dec. 21, 2025. The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) voted 4 to 1 to approve the increase in a public meeting held Dec. 19, according to the Los Angeles Times and other outlets. 
 
Pacific Gas & Electric Co. (PG&E) still needs approval from the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to keep Diablo Canyon open. The NRC is considering a 20-year license extension and staff have said they could finish their review of the utility’s license extension application by August 2025 or so. 
 
The California commission so far has approved PG&E to keep the plant open for only five of the 20 years the utility could get tacked on to its federal.
 
PG&E’s operating licenses for Diablo Canyon Unit 1 expired on Nov. 2, but NRC has allowed the reactor to stay online while federal staff vet the utility’s license renewal application. Unit 2’s license will lapse on Aug. 26 2025. 
 
Antinuclear activists have opposed Diablo Canyon’s license extension both in federal court and as part of the NRC’s ongoing review.
 
Nuclear waste is spread across 94 different nuclear sites in the U.S. and has no permanent home. Big Tech is going to add more to the pile.
Subject: Summary of November 22, 2024, Partially Closed Observation Meeting with Constellation Energy Generation, LLC Regarding Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station, Units 2 and 3 Digital Upgrade of the Emergency Core Cooling System Compensated Level System
 
ADAMS Accession No.: ML24344A227
 
 
Using Web-based ADAMS, select “Advanced Search”
Under “Property,” select “Accession Number”
Under “Value,” enter the Accession Number
Click Search.
Subject: Susquehanna Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2 – Acceptance of Requested Licensing Action Re: LAR for ILRT interval and TS (EPID L-2024-LLA-0148)
 
ADAMS Accession No.: ML24344A276
 
 
Using Web-based ADAMS, select “Advanced Search”
Under “Property,” select “Accession Number”
Under “Value,” enter the Accession Number
Click Search. 
Nuclear Regulatory Commission - News Release
No: I-24-020 December 16, 2024
CONTACT: Diane Screnci, 610-337-5330
Neil Sheehan, 610-337-5331

NRC Issues Order Prohibiting Former Manager for Pennsylvania Firm from NRC-related Activities for Three Years

The Nuclear Regulatory Commission is issuing an order prohibiting a former manager for a Pennsylvania radiography firm from involvement in NRC-licensed activities for three years due to deliberate misconduct. The order stems from a failure to adhere to safety requirements during radiography work conducted at a temporary job site in West Virginia.
 
Titan Inspection LLC, based in Montoursville, Pennsylvania, carried out industrial radiography activities in 2022 near Wheeling, West Virginia, and did not meet NRC requirements regarding radiographer staffing. An investigation by the NRC’s Office of Investigation determined that the radiographer assigned to the job and the former Titan manager were aware of the regulatory requirement but did not secure an assistant radiographer prior to performing work at the job site.
 
The NRC issued Severity Level III Notices of Violations to the company and the former radiographer earlier this year, as a result of the concerns identified.
 
Industrial radiography involves the use of a device containing nuclear material to check for cracks or flaws in materials that would not otherwise be visible.
 

https://www.risch.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/pressreleases?ID=628A2843-553B-4E6B-8482-D80D15715EEB#:~:text=The%20ARC%20Act%20establishes%20a,energy%20projects%20to%20jumpstart%20commercialization.

Risch Introduces Bill to Accelerate New Nuclear Investment

December 4, 2024

WASHINGTON - U.S. Senator Jim Risch (R-Idaho) today introduced the Accelerating Reliable Capacity (ARC) Act to accelerate investment in new commercial nuclear projects by minimizing cost overrun risk.

“We are at the cusp of unlocking a host of advanced reactor technologies, which are essential to meet growing domestic energy demands and strengthening our national security. While the U.S. has made significant investments in developing new nuclear reactors, the financial risk in moving from demonstration to commercialization is so significant, it impedes industry growth,” said Risch. “The ARC Act aims to mitigate that risk and ensure the U.S. remains the global leader in nuclear energy.”

Building new nuclear reactor technologies for the first time creates significant upfront cost and timing uncertainties, which make it challenging to attract investments. The ARC Act establishes a limited risk reduction program for building new commercial reactors by providing a backstop for unforeseen costs through enhanced financing terms. The program would benefit three or more next generation nuclear energy projects to jumpstart commercialization.

Senator Risch is a long-time advocate for nuclear energy. He has spearheaded legislation to increase domestic energy production, enhance national security, and keep the United States at the forefront of nuclear advancement. He is the founder and co-chair of the Senate Advanced Nuclear Caucus, which amplifies the critical role nuclear energy plays in the U.S. and explores emerging nuclear technologies.

"I commend Senator Risch for his longstanding support of nuclear energy and his commitment to our nation’s energy security and prosperity,” said John Wagner, Director of the Idaho National Lab. “The near-term expansion of nuclear energy is essential to meeting the dramatic demand growth for clean, reliable power necessary for our industrial sector and economic competitiveness. Providing additional certainty to early adopters will help mitigate risks for nuclear projects and encourage the investment needed to accelerate the deployment of new reactors."

"The Accelerating Reliable Capacity Act of 2024 is a pivotal step in addressing the financial barriers that have hindered the deployment of new nuclear reactors. With essential financing solutions, this legislation will accelerate the development of advanced nuclear technology, enhance U.S. energy independence, and strengthen our global leadership in clean energy innovation," said Maria Korsnick, president and CEO of the Nuclear Energy Institute. "We commend Senator Risch's leadership on this critical issue and look forward to working with Congress to advance this important bill."

"The demand for clean, reliable energy is driving renewed interest in nuclear energy," said ClearPath Action CEO Jeremy Harrell. "The faster nuclear projects get off the ground the faster the U.S. can build critical technologies like data centers and new manufacturing facilities. The ARC Act seeks to supercharge the deployment of new nuclear projects to meet this need." 

Permalink: https://www.risch.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2024/12/risch-introduces-bill-to-accelerate-new-nuclear-investment

Good afternoon Eric,
 
Here is our article about Three Mile Island (Google translate might help)
Thank you again for our participation
Best regards
 
 
PS the radio version is in the same link, just click on this in the article
 
 
US Correspondent/Correspondant aux États-Unis
Radio-Canada/CBC
Washington, DC 
 
https://twitter.com/fredericarnould?lang=fr

SUN DAY CAMPAIGN

8606 Greenwood Avenue, Suite #2; Takoma Park, MD 20912-6656  
Twitter: Follow @SunDayCampaign  
   
   
Brief News Update & Analysis  
   
 
SOLAR IS 78% OF NEW US GENERATING CAPACITY YTD
AND THE LARGEST SOURCE OF NEW CAPACITY
FOR 13 MONTHS STRAIGHT
 
AT 11% OF NEW CAPACITY, WIND ADDED MORE
THAN NATURAL GAS & NUCLEAR POWER COMBINED
 
MIX OF ALL RENEWABLES HAS PROVIDED
90% OF NEW CAPACITY IN 2024 YTD
 
 
For Release:  Monday, December 2, 2024
 
Contact:         Ken Bossong, 301-588-4741
 
Washington DC – A review by the SUN DAY Campaign of data newly released by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) reveals that the mix of renewable energy sources (i.e., biomass, geothermal, hydropower, solar, wind) accounted for almost 90% of total U.S. electrical generating capacity added in the first three-quarters of 2024. Moreover, September was the thirteenth month in a row in which solar was the largest source of new capacity.
 
 
Renewables were 82.4% of new generating capacity in September and 89.6% in first three-quarters of 2024:
 
In its latest monthly “Energy Infrastructure Update” (with data through September 30, 2024), FERC says 47 “units” of solar totaling 1,786 megawatts (MW) were placed into service in September along with two units of wind (156-MW) and one unit of hydropower (1-MW). Combined they accounted for 82.4% of all new generating capacity added during the month. Natural gas provided the balance: 410-MW. [1]
 
During the first nine months of 2024, solar and wind added 18,635-MW and 2,626-MW respectively. Combined with 213-MW of hydropower and 6-MW of biomass, renewables were 89.6% of capacity added. The balance consisted of the 1,100 Vogtle-4 nuclear reactor in Georgia plus 1,387-MW of gas, 11-MW of oil, and 8-MW of “other.”
 
 
Solar was 75.7% of new capacity in September and 77.7% during the first nine months of 2024:
 
Solar has now been the largest source of new generating capacity added each month for thirteen months straight: September 2023 – September 2024.
 
The new solar capacity added from January through September accounted for 77.7% of all new generation placed into service for the period.
 
In September alone, solar comprised 75.7% of all new capacity added.
 
Adjusting for the differences in capacity factors among solar, nuclear power, and natural gas, the new solar capacity added thus far in 2024 is likely to generate more than four times as much electricity as the new nuclear capacity and over five times as much as might be expected from the new natural gas capacity. [2]
 
 
Solar plus wind are now more than 21% of U.S. generating capacity; all renewables combined are 30.3%:
 
New wind capacity accounted for much of the balance YTD (10.9%) which is more than the new natural gas capacity (5.8%) and nuclear power capacity (4.6%) combined. New solar capacity is approximately seven and one-half times that of the combination of natural gas and nuclear power.
 
Taken together, the installed capacities of just solar (9.4%) and wind (11.8%) now constitute more than one-fifth (21.2%) of the nation’s total available installed utility-scale generating capacity: wind – 11.8%; solar – 9.4%.
 
However, approximately 30% of U.S. solar capacity is in the form of small-scale (e.g., rooftop) systems that is not reflected in FERC’s data. [3] Including that additional solar capacity would bring the share provided by solar + wind closer to a quarter of the nation’s total.
 
With the inclusion of hydropower (7.7%), biomass (1.1%) and geothermal (0.3%), renewables now claim a 30.3% share of total U.S. utility-scale generating capacity.
 
 
Solar’s share of installed U.S. generating capacity is greater than either nuclear power or hydropower:
 
The latest capacity additions have brought solar’s share of total available installed utility-scale (i.e., >1-MW) generating capacity up to 9.4%, further expanding its lead over nuclear power (7.9%) as well as hydropower (7.7%).
 
Installed utility-scale solar has now moved into fourth place – behind natural gas (43.4%), coal (15.5%) and wind (11.8%) - for its share of generating capacity.
 
 
Solar will soon become the second largest source of U.S. generating capacity:
 
FERC reports that net “high probability” additions of solar between October 2024 and September 2027 total 94,491-MW – an amount more than four times the forecast net “high probability” additions for wind (22,711-MW), the second fastest growing resource. FERC also foresees growth for hydropower (1,290-MW), biomass (124-MW), and geothermal (90-MW).
 
Taken together, the net new “high probability” capacity additions by all renewable energy sources would total 118,706-MW with solar comprising nearly 80% and wind providing another 19%.  
 
On the other hand, there is no new nuclear capacity in FERC’s three-year forecast while coal, oil, and natural gas are projected to contract by 19,863-MW, 2,244-MW, and 1,145-MW respectively.
 
If FERC’s current “high probability” additions materialize, by October 1, 2027, solar will account for nearly one-sixth (15.5%) of the nation’s installed utility-scale generating capacity. That would be greater than either coal (13.0%) or wind (12.6%) and substantially more than either nuclear power (7.4%) or hydropower (7.3%).
 
In fact, assuming current growth rates continue, the installed capacity of utility-scale solar is likely to surpass coal and wind within the next two years, placing solar in second place for installed generating capacity – behind only natural gas.
 
Meanwhile, the mix of all renewables is adding about two percentage points each year to its share of generating capacity. Thus, by September 30, 2027, renewables would account for 36.7% of total available installed utility-scale generating capacity - rapidly approaching that of natural gas (40.3%) - with solar and wind constituting more than three-quarters of the installed renewable energy capacity.
 
 
The combined capacities of all renewables, including small-scale solar, remain on track to exceed natural gas within three years:
 
As noted, FERC’s data do not account for the capacity of small-scale solar systems. If that is factored in, within three years, total U.S. solar capacity (i.e., small-scale plus utility-scale) is likely to surpass 300-GW. In turn, the mix of all renewables would then exceed 40% of total installed capacity while natural gas’ share would drop to about 37%.
 
Moreover, FERC reports that there may actually be as much as 216,989-MW of net new solar additions in the current three-year pipeline in addition to 66,308-MW of new wind, 9,131-MW of new hydropower, 199-MW of new geothermal, and 195-MW of new biomass. By contrast, net new natural gas capacity potentially in the three-year pipeline totals just 18,029-MW. Thus, renewables’ share could be even greater by early fall 2027.
 
 
"New solar capacity added in 2024 thus far will produce more electricity than will be generated by new nuclear power and natural gas additions," noted the SUN DAY Campaign's executive director Ken Bossong. "Unless derailed by the incoming Trump Administration, solar - which has now been top dog for 13 months straight - is poised to continue dominating capacity additions for at least the next three years." 
  
# # # # # # # # #  
   
Source:  
FERC's 6-page "Energy Infrastructure Update for September 2024" was released on November 29, 2024, and can be found at: https://cms.ferc.gov/media/energy-infrastructure-update-september-2024.
 
For the information cited in this update, see the tables entitled "New Generation In-Service (New Build and Expansion)," "Total Available Installed Generating Capacity," and "Generation Capacity Additions and Retirements."

Notes:   
[1] Generating capacity is not the same as actual generation. Fossil fuels and nuclear power generally have higher "capacity factors" than do wind and solar (see Note #2 below).
 
[2] EIA reports capacity factors in calendar year 2023 for nuclear power and combined-cycle natural gas plants were 93.0% and 59.7% respectively while those for wind and utility-scale solar PV were 33.2% and 23.2%. See Tables 6.07.A and 6.07.B in EIA's most recent "Electric Power Monthly" report. 

[3] In a September 12, 2023 news release, EIA states: “More than one-third of U.S. solar power capacity is small-scale solar. … We expect small-scale solar capacity … will grow from 44-GW in June 2023 to 55-GW by the end of 2024.” See: https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/steo/report/BTL/2023/09-smallscalesolar/article.php
 
# # # # # # # # # 
   
The SUN DAY Campaign is a non-profit research and educational organization founded in 1992 to support a rapid transition to 100% reliance on sustainable energy technologies as a cost-effective alternative to nuclear power and fossil fuels and as a solution to climate change. Follow on Twitter (or “X”): @SunDayCampaign  
Thanks to Bob Schaeffer for finding this. Nov 2024 report from Kerrisdale Capital on Oklo. References IEEFA's SMR/new reactors cost chart (page 10) and even hyperlinks on page 1 to the term "Nuclear Bros." to Dr. Ed Lyman's great blog.
 
Excerpt: We believe investors should be wary of unsubstantiated claims spouted by these "Nuclear Bros.” Recent SMR projects have experienced dramatic cost escalation, Oklo does not have the long-term supply of enriched uranium fuel it needs (and won’t well into the 2030s), and sodium-cooled reactors have well-documented reliability problems.  

https://www.kerrisdalecap.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/OKLO-Kerrisdale.pdf

Pages